Comparison of Longley-Rice, ITU-R P.1546 and Hata-Davidson propagation models for DVB-T coverage prediction

Abstract

This paper compares precision field-strength measurements taken by a Rohde & Schwarz FSH-3 portable spectrum analyzer with simulation results derived from the ITM coverage prediction model (Irregular Terrain Model), also known as NTIA-ITS Longley-Rice model, in conjunction with the 3-arc-second SRTM (Satellite Radar Topography Mission) geographical data, the propagation predictions of ITU-R Recommendation P. 1546 and those of the empirical Hata-Davidson model using HAAT. ITU-R P. 1546 and Hata-Davidson models exhibit higher errors at longer distances and therefore necessary corrections should be introduced in the models in order to increase propagation prediction accuracy. Especially, measurements results show that ITU-R P.1546, on average, underestimates the field strength at distances longer than 50 km. The Longley-Rice model using the terrain digital elevations is more accurate, as expected, and its results are closer to the measurement data. © 2014 IEEE.