| Title: | Determination of the spin and parity of all-charm tetraquarks |
| Authors: | Hayrapetyan, A Makarenko, V Tumasyan, A Adam, W Andrejkovic, JW Benato, L Bergauer, T Dragicevic, M Giordano, C Hussain, PS Jeitler, M Townsend, A Chitroda, BK Summers, S Kovalskyi, D Taus, R Bansal, S Banerjee, S Maggi, M Snyder, C Stäger, F Jesus, SS Chen, X Krasnikov, N Margjeka, I Natoli, J Roy, T Xiao, M Lintuluoto, A Karchin, PE Mastrapasqua, V Stuart, D Lyon, A-M Wan, Y Kwok, KHM Kaluzinska, O Langford, J Moon, DH Zorbakir, IS My, S Nenna, F Nuzzo, S Pellecchia, A Holmberg, M-L Dharmender, D Bulla, ACM Mohanty, GB Winterbottom, D Schröder, M Milosevic, J Giannini, L Bhattacharya, S Ortona, G Sharma, R Treille, D Menichelli, M Bendavid, J Pompili, A Gottmann, A Lunerti, L Zisopoulos, I Beri, SB Gregores, EM Baxter, S Gu, Y Kim, T Osterberg, K Harris, P Camporesi, T Legger, F Alazemi, F Tali, B Mijuskovic, J Chauhan, S Sanchez, A Lanteri, L Herrera, RP Delannoy, AG Bethani, A Boccali, T Watson, IJ Lawhorn, JM Zoi, I Chatzistavrou, T Vourliotis, E Haeberle, R Awais, A Baringer, P Nash, J Tramontano, R Zou, R Pugliese, G Hirschauer, J Pérez Adán, D Smith, VJ Menasce, D Oh, BH You, Z Shahzad, MA Ragazzi, S Radogna, R Bayatmakou, M Ramos, D Lomte, S Oshiro, M Lopez, SG Favilla, L Zhizhin, I Wynne, RA Guiang, J Barbagli, G Pacher, L Oppenländer, V Muhammed Rafeek, RK Ranieri, A Oh, YD Silvestris, L Gasparini, U Forthomme, L Karacheban, O Asawatangtrakuldee, C Funk, W Saha, NR Chen, M Rinkevicius, A Monti, F Fernandez Perez Tomei, TR Shang, V Dengra, CP Simone, FM Qian, SJ Gonzalez, HB Garutti, E Mechelen, PV Xie, S Harris, J Zotto, P Pikurs, G Klein, K Deng, S Prosper, H Sözbilir, Ü Stamerra, A Yzquierdo, AP-C Masterson, P Noonan, D Messineo, A Blend, D Troiano, D Da Molin, G Naimuddin, M Ahmad, A Bean, A Dash, G Royon, C Cavanaugh, R Leonardo, N Venditti, R Druzhkin, D Wightman, A Bruno, G Williams, T Lipinski, M Fan, X Kim, Y Verwilligen, P Wayne, M Appelt, E Chiarito, B Zaza, A Karathanasis, G Bornheim, A Behnke, O Jayatilaka, B Mignerey, AC Aravind, A Fabbri, F Bemden, MV Karmakar, S Fayer, S Schwick, C Schwandt, J Laurila, S Meyer, AB Klute, M Krutelyov, V Jofrehei, A Hiltbrand, J Yockey, H Abbiendi, G Maeshima, K Battilana, C Carretero, OM Mariotti, C Ajmal, S Tsoi, HF Hebbeker, T Sexton-Kennedy, E Bonacorsi, D Androsov, K Figueroa, KM Ershov, A Capiluppi, P Cavallo, FR Belvedere, A Goldstein, J Neogi, O Kravchenko, I Geurts, FJM Dallavalle, GM Zhang, M Pelayo, JP Jindariani, S Cui, Z Sirasva, BK Tropea, P Tiwari, PC Nissan, Y Da Costa, EM Eliseev, D Reyes-Almanza, R Jourd’huy, E Field, RD Macedo, M Papanastassiou, A Röwert, N Mason, D Cepeda, M Ghezzi, A Lee, R Hussein, A Tonjes, MB Perovic, V Paasch, A Vellidis, K Bihan, A-CL Braghieri, A Redondo, I Escobar, JV Lukashenko, V Zehetner, P Rand, B de Trocóniz, JF Martin, MA Di Florio, A Zalewski, P Liu, J Sommerhalder, M Mills, C Yalvac, M Butler, JN Nürnberg, A Wolf, M Gonzalez, BA Mercadante, PG Sharma, A Lecoq, P Jung, AW Piotrzkowski, K Wang, H Backhaus, M Vámi, TÁ Hoepfner, K Wang, C Sorrentino, G Vetens, W Csorgo, T Rose, A Ivanov, K Hong, Y Kim, T Reichert, J Kao, YW Dell’Orso, R Kondratyev, D Candelise, V Brommer, S Hu, Z Torresano, JA Cardini, A Hernandez, JM Fidalgo, G De La Cruz, B Bam, B Milosevic, V Samudio, J Pastrone, N Shukla, R Nattland, P Szanyi, I Cuevas, J Mrowietz, M Badas, JDR Danilov, M Gallo, E Bylund, OB Cappati, A Acevedo, DE Crossman, B Hadjiagapiou, A Menendez, JF Dimitrov, A Li, C Horzela, M Viinikainen, J Hadjiiska, R Letts, J Sguazzoni, G Folgueras, S McBride, P Ball, AH Vanlaer, P Fanfani, A Caballero, IG Kole, G Hsu, TH Alsufyani, B Rekovic, V Zolkapli, Z Malara, A Rovelli, T Lehtela, B Zejdl, P Giómez Espinosa, TA Calzaferri, S Leguina, P Baden, A Burkett, K Bauerdick, LAT Murthy, S Wang, D Patterson, JR Basnet, A Viliani, L Menendez, MO Vlasov, E Tapper, A Richards, A Vannerom, D Seidel, M Novaes, SF Hall, AR Parolia, S Spah, JL Tenchini, R Cortezon, EP Caminada, L Massironi, A Garcia, F Li, YY Calligaris, L Merkel, P Ruspa, M Pico, JP Menzio, L Cranshaw, DJ Soto Rodríguez, A Lee, C Singh, N Phan, T Ravera, F Chawla, R Eysermans, J Lavinsky, M Li, H Liu, M Safdari, M Kotamnives, P Montagna, P Villalba, CV Meena, M De Cosa, A Vischia, P Raicevic, N Maier, S Kozyrev, A Rudrabhatla, S Chudasama, R Blanco Fernández, S Kim, MR Khan, A Agrawal, A Bright-Thonney, S Schmieder, R Guchait, M Andrade, ARA Dreimanis, K Cabrillo, IJ de Fatis, TT Wu, HY Nair Bindhu, VKM Chen, Y Marcellini, S Lange, T Uchida, K Vernazza, E Mussgiller, A Selvaggi, M Kim, HS Macchiolo, A Belloni, A Calderon, A Campderros, JD Taylor, L D’Alessandro, R Kadhim, AA Fernandez, M Smith, C Elicabuk, U Kasemann, M Gogate, N Skovpen, K Ozdemir, K Cipriani, M Bossi, H Halkiadakis, E Shooshtari, M Warden, A Orzari, B Harilal, A Saha, P Petkov, P Chen, YC Prova, PR Poncet, O Siviero, F Kioseoglou, PGK Gomez, G Pata, J Bundock, A Teroerde, M Sen, S Hussain, MM Lasaosa García, C Mormile, M Ruiz, RL Hou, X Silverio, IM Bak, G Dominguez, A Kaestli, HC Aebi, D Rivero, CM Paganoni, M Donato, S Johnson, M Bonomelli, G Cagnotta, A Lu, R-S Bevilacqua, T Della Porta, GZ Verma, P Dinardo, ME Chaudhary, G Krolikowski, J Hong, J Salur, S Lee, S Ruiz del Arbol, PM Verdini, PG Pelliccioni, M Fasanella, D Ko, B Müller, D Loeliger, A Lanev, A Carrigan, M Cetorelli, F Ptochos, F Matorras, F Ceard, L Yagil, A Painesis, Z Kwok, TH Mrenna, S Bainbridge, R Giacomelli, P Santos, RDL Cole, JE Kodolova, O Cuevas, PM Ramos, EN Gomez, JP Lavezzo, L Giorgetti, S Thakur, S Schnetzer, S Quintana San Emeterio, C Lehti, S Jun, W Lustermann, W Sola, V Saha, G Müller, T Grandi, C Henao, DO Kamble, S Tharayil, AK Kim, J Camagni, V Bunichev, V Uttley, GP Wang, F Loveless, R Perraguin, AB Kazana, M Padula, SS Scodellaro, L Nahn, S Guiducci, L Martikainen, L Afanasiev, S Yetkin, T Gray, L Pásztor, G Komaragiri, JR Zhao, J Sosnov, D Daumann, C Organtini, G Vila, I Parida, G Kanemura, M Cortabitarte, RV Rykaczewski, H Everaerts, P Knolle, J De Oliveira, TM Kleinwort, C Bistany-riebman, J Cousins, R Vora, J Kim, Y Hos, I Grassi, J Garcia, JMV Kailasapathy, B Wickramarathna, DDC Dharmaratna, WGD Dutta, I Fouz, MC Re, V Darwish, MR Durkin, LS Wulz, C-E Maghrbi, Y Vaucelle, P Masciovecchio, M Teryaev, O Liyanage, K Rolandi, G Monteno, M Kim, YW Lazarovits, M Alvarez, JDR Atakisi, IO Kim, V Virdee, T Tsai, LS Linacre, J Paramatti, R Arbour, C Thomas-Wilsker, J Roh, Y Pfeffer, E Härringer, N Gomez-Ceballos, G Alexe, CA Kamon, T Godinovic, N León Holgado, J Alexakhin, V Liu, C Hindrichs, O Perera, N Potrebko, A Masetti, G Qian, S Heath, HF Chhetri, A Solano, A Benussi, L Abbaneo, D Mankel, R Bodek, A Kapoor, A Lee, JSH Negro, G Beyrouthy, T Agyel, D Tedeschi, T Scheurer, V Chou, PC Amendola, C Wanczyk, J Maier, B Schonbeck, N Gadallah, MMA Tomalin, IR Roland, G Niedziela, J Gleyzer, SV Eno, SC Kaur, H Colafranceschi, S Neumeister, N Reithler, H Ingram, Q Chen, GM Meo, SL Juodagalvis, A Ardino, R Auffray, E Khukhunaishvili, A Hohlmann, M Baechler, J Vojinovic, M Arneodo, M Law, KH Andreev, Y Gribushin, A Kim, H Barney, D Inkaew, P Penzo, A Lincoln, D Kang, DY Rotter, J Dadazhanova, O Bianco, M Diekmann, S Bocci, A Sculac, A Meola, S Ferencek, D Saka, H Kogler, R Caillol, C Cumalat, JP Ngadiuba, J Rogan, C Malek, P Spiga, D Hill, C Alison, J Trujillo, DAB Borgonovi, L Higginbotham, S Reis, MC Sawant, S Ranken, E Siroli, GP Bolshov, A Botta, C Murray, M Selivanova, D Bragagnolo, A Hadley, NJ Piccolo, D Cosby, C Guadarrama, DLR Aleksandrov, A Matchev, K Somalwar, S Maksimovic, P Fernández Ramos, JP Mokhtar, F Jackson, WJ Ventura, S Rossi, AM Strautnieks, NR Tiras, E Umoret, G De Favereau De Jeneret, J Mazza, M Jiang, CH Lascio, S Joyce, M He, H Rizzi, A Casarsa, M Pearson, E Perez, CU Dutta, V Sharma, V Ivone, F Carnevali, F Hou, Q Farkas, K Coelho, E Hogan, S Donnelly, S Moroni, L Li, A Liao, H Karapostoli, G Sánchez Hernández, A Innocenti, GM Ranjan, K Incandela, J Costa, S Susa, T Malakhov, A Raspereza, A Stoynev, S Clement, E Jung, A Terrill, W De Leo, K Nanda, S Ascioti, ME Rumerio, P Usai, E Asilar, E Hogan, JM Nguyen, D Brinkerhoff, A Bandyopadhyay, H Dolek, F Bloom, K Yi, R Filho, MBF Long, K Benaglia, A Ramírez García, M Presilla, M Cholak, S Luongo, F De Castro, G Manthos, N Rossi, A Coll Saravia, LX Ornelas, MN Malgeri, L Demiragli, Z Jakovcic, K Hofsaess, R Cerminara, G Erice, C Ford, WT Velkovska, J Yang, YC Giffels, M Giani, S Tadel, M Wildridge, A Kotlinski, D Fangmeier, C Matveev, V Clark, SV Kyriacou, S Osite, D Mannelli, M Madrazo, CF Topaksu, AK Tran, NV Spiegel, L Khalilzadeh, A Sahasransu, AR Kousouris, K Choi, J Würthwein, F Rabady, D Thachayath, A Hart, A Harte, TG Holmes, T Dumanoglu, I Fontanesi, E Liu, G Galloni, C Black, K Ahmad, M Amram, D Zarubin, A Cardwell, B Wenzl, DA Boudoul, G Lange, C Fulcher, J Li, AJ Mcginn, C Hoang, D Asenov, P Wang, D Kamenev, A Golf, F Hossain, J Laktineh, IB Toropin, A Josa, MI Bortolato, G Manolopoulos, K Jeon, S Pearkes, J Seidita, R Jaiswal, A Uplegger, L Mukherjee, S Malvezzi, S Boyaryntsev, A Nikitenko, A O’Cain, J Reed, I Kontos, DS Greene, S Rohlf, J Kirsanov, M Hensel, C Lidrych, J Dickinson, J Popova, E Tlisova, I Engelke, F Jaffel, K Velde, CV Xie, W Kumar, N Yuldashev, BS Romeo, F Guler, Y Tonelli, G Salyer, K Mahon, D Navarria, FL Ryd, A Sperka, D Azzurri, P Kim, TJ León Coello, M Yuan, L Kharchilava, A Pedraza, I Spitzbart, D Marchegiani, M Martinez, G Walter, D Hoeflich, N Yang, H Yoo, J Peris, AD Palmeri, N Lee, MY Isildak, B Suarez, I Jin, W Cherepanov, V Connor, P Segal, J Steinbrück, G Mulders, M Vijay, A Novak, A Palit, P Frankenthal, A Mishra, S Cremonesi, M Kanuganti, AR Lipton, R d’Enterria, D Liu, Z-A Tsatsos, A Wurtz, E Boos, E Wang, J Davis, J Song, J Zecchinelli, AG Liang, Z Lee, D Bagliesi, G Dabrowski, A Rodriguez, KJP Colino, N Askew, A Bury, F Klanner, R Wang, J Melzer-Pellmann, I-A Waltenberger, W Siamarkou, E Barone, G Karunarathna, N David, A Rastorguev, D Berry, D Zhao, Y Nemes, F Evard, H Paggi, G Benelli, G Eberlins, OM Cutts, D Bhatt, L Varelas, N Onel, Y Dini, P Barnett, N Marinelli, N Nowotny, F Yigitbasi, E Ellis, S Ryou, Y Gouskos, L Park, MI Yu, SS Papageorgakis, C Tabb, W Köseyan, OK Ulmer, KA Sulimov, V Bonanomi, M Hadley, M Valsecchi, D Cussans, D Dimova, T Monroy, J Haller, J Vaandering, EW Kwan, S Kuo, CM Lethuillier, M Hassani, A Devetak, D Eble, F Ibarguen, HAS Muhammad, A Pena, C Rygaard, L Yao, Y Heintz, U Reis, T Cummings, G Maestre, JA Guler, EG Mehta, A Song, JN Lavizzari, G Meuser, D Ujvari, B Chanon, N Dittmar, M Tsipolitis, G Bennett, C Ho, KW Sheng, TA Ristori, L Huang, T Kim, S Lammel, S Palichik, V Ivanov, A Meijers, F Contardo, D Bardelli, G Stephans, GSF Fehérkuti, A Staiano, A Kwon, T Landsberg, G Lau, KT Avila, C Iorio, AD Pedro, K Scham, M Shchedrolosiev, M Luo, J Bahinipati, S Nelson, T Robertshaw, L Bhat, PC Mondal, S Perrotta, A Ha, S Merlin, JA Mishra, T Dugad, S Seixas, J Lawless, J Gorbunov, I Dissertori, G Paspalaki, G Baradia, S Paus, C Sarkar, U Wassmer, M Hay, L Gigi, D Yang, UK Roloff, J Russell, T Perelygin, V Mersi, S Heindl, M Fedi, G Bestintzanos, I Pradhan, R Sharma, V Winer, BL Gallegos Maríñez, LG Varela, J Zhong, Y Sahu, B Gennai, S Hoorani, HR Sutantawibul, C Sagir, S Daskalakis, G Lee, L Yoon, I Diemoz, M Shen, X Veres, GI Stockmeier, L Fokow, P Ozkorucuklu, S Bhattacharya, R Song, S Dodonova, A Elmer, P Stafford, D Yates, BR Shulha, S Franco, RE Melo, A Stamenkovic, M Venkatasubramanian, N Abbott, S Barton, B Mondal, S Mudholkar, T McMaster, B Jarrin, EC Isik, C Mans, J Depasse, P Erdmann, J Konigsberg, J Primavera, F Parashar, N Kumar, S Breedon, R Sarkisla, MA Schöfbeck, R Brew, C Howard, A Krammer, N Litov, L Dozen, C Wulansatiti, M Saini, MK Reissel, C Avery, P Flowers, Z Johns, W Sun, X Krueper, P Kress, T Aruta, C Cabrera, A Han, S Apresyan, A Bauer, G Kaynak, B Lange, J Brown, RM Purohit, A De Roeck, A Barrera, CB Evangelou, I Nibigira, E Hinzmann, A Cai, H Schnake, S Musich, M Savin, A Kansal, R Ogul, H Bluj, M Lee, SW De La Barca Sanchez, MC Langenegger, U Chertok, M Forti, R Eckerlin, G Hsia, HW Guo, B Argiro, S Mausolf, F El Mamouni, H Korytov, A Moortgat, F Hacisahinoglu, B Citron, M Zhou, C Conway, J Park, K Cali, IA Bouchamaoui, H Feng, Y Hernandez, AC Sanders, S Lelas, D Cho, G Palla, F Rappoccio, S Tao, J Asghar, MI Missiroli, M Chen, KF Merschmeyer, M Lista, L Stenson, K Marquez, J Meschi, E Huerta, FEN Chwalek, T Cox, PT Erbacher, R Sfar, HR Santos, AZC Elvira, VD Thomas, L Kukral, O Roland, C Pesaresi, M Shevelev, A Foudas, C Wardle, N Rádl, AJ Rothman, S Mocellin, G Petyt, D Joshi, BM De Souza, SF Klyukhin, V Iaydjiev, P Blekman, F Roy, P Ostrom, S Riccardi, C Gerosa, R Segovia, IS Coldham, K Erdmann, M Noehte, L Schütze, P Bhatnagar, V Bianchini, L Datta, A Flanagan, P Petrushanko, S Piperov, S Javaid, T Das, P Pauss, F Aydilek, O Fay, J Thomas, S Raidal, M Wei, W Wang, Q Yoo, S Claes, DR Chang, P Fan, J Chowdhury, SR Lopes, BR Grohsjean, A Adamidis, K Petrov, A Venturi, A Bachtis, M Wang, C Rohe, T Mallampalli, A Wolf, R Barman, S Meschini, M Campos, D Williams, A Schwanenberger, C Thiel, M Hatakeyama, K Pathak, A Starodumov, A Yazgan, E Lee, J Pfeiffer, A Yi, K Nikolopoulos, K Kuhn, TL Zhao, Z Neutelings, I Bruyn, ID Haza, G De Oliveira, ACA Gascon, S Ortega, JC Toms, M Belyaev, A Defranchis, MM Wagner, SR Young, P Yu, D Fiorendi, S Carnahan, T Palluotto, S Alverson, G Erdmann, W Goncharov, M Yusuff, I Kara, O Quast, G Rathjens, D Lohmann, W Tarabini, A Tok, UG Barberis, E Kim, B Dezoort, G Mattia, AD Li, Y Bunkowski, K Zhang, Y Eich, N Riti, F Labe, F Zilizi, G Sarkar, T Oreshkin, V Malbouisson, HB Tarricone, C Alhusseini, M Pedrini, D Eusebi, R Canepa, A Delaere, C Bower, S Uslan, E Bonilla, J Bylsma, B Iashvili, I Lindén, T Rohilla, A Verma, RK Kapsiak, C Tani, L Menendez, N Finger, M Hall, G Campana, M Tsionou, D Florez, C Turini, N De Bryas Dexmiers D’archiacchiac, P Robutti, E Hong, B Dervan, J Pujahari, PR Haddad, Y Gaile, A Bubanja, I Cankocak, K Mariani, V Gharbia, Y Gouzevitch, M Barzdukas, A Han, Y Wichmann, K Tae, B Avila, GF Israr, I Gilmore, J D’Amante, V Faltermann, N Rusack, R Allmond, B Lee, J Arora, A Ecklund, KM Sarkisovi, V Zipper, N Krishna, A Bencze, G Lipka, K Krücker, D Zaleski, S Sznajder, A Eckstein, D Brennan, L Lu, M Wang, J Dubinin, M Murzin, V Cossutti, F Popescu, S Kim, S Fischer, Y Campbell, S Manganelli, N Gardner, P Cerri, O Perez, CM Guo, Y Berryhill, J Wiens, L Mitselmakher, G Mccarthy, R Huh, C Morse, DM Vazzoler, F Tauqeer, K Shadskiy, N El Morabit, K Tisbeni, SR Choudhary, BC Hartmann, F Greenberg, C Lapertosa, A Putte, SV Zuolo, D Orimoto, T Deile, M Demina, R Fraga, J Zhang, J Potok, O Di Marco, E Sikler, F Parker, A Yan, X El-mahdy, B Damenti, L Singh, JB Simsek, E Bartek, R Bhowmik, D Grove, D Skinnari, L Akchurin, N Gandrakota, A Salvini, P Wang, J Del Val, DF Savrin, V Shumka, E Ristic, B Kovac, M Prifti, E Czellar, S Thoreson, CS Tsai, E Keicher, P Pieri, M Tews, A Wood, D Csanád, M Gülmez, E Gedia, K Seo, J Gurrola, A Mao, Y Sheokand, T Lucchini, MT Mecca, A Soeiro, M Lee, K Schmidt, A Perego, A Bhardwaj, A Dierlamm, A Liko, D Mohrman, K Moallemi, M Dittmer, S Da Costa, BL Nicolaou, C Orfanelli, S Cox, B Hahn, KA Sert, H Liu, Y Acosta, HAE Hwang, K Baty, A Brücken, E Krommydas, I Checchia, P Mcginnis, M Cerati, GB Das, AK Bargassa, P Lusiani, E Janssen, T Freed, S Fernández Manteca, PJ Collins, E Sarica, U Knight, CR Pinolini, BS Nigmatkulov, G Miao, Y Klijnsma, T Schwarz, D Hauser, J Huang, Z White, R Lorusso, M Errico, F Richman, J Nadderd, L Vega, JAR Akhter, T Xiao, J Sanjrani, MS Ally, D Wissing, C Korenkov, V Ignatenko, M Assran, Y De Riggi, F Monk, DG Schmitt, MH Taliercio, A Mukherjee, S Paulini, M Mundim, L Pizzati, G Velasco, M Wadud, MA Chou, JP Madhu, AM Antchev, G Simsek, C Iqbal, MA Obertino, MM Kyberd, P Tavernier, S Yoo, J Cartiglia, N Snigirev, A Bartolini, M Giassi, A Lampén, T Freer, C Yoo, HD Wang, J Yang, Y Lam, T Scribano, A Bose, T Clerbaux, B Buchmuller, O Reid, ID Barrera, CO Biino, C Pantaleo, F Norberg, S Agarwal, G Seth, C Band, R Stojanovic, M Herrera, CM Damiao, DDJ Bhyun, JH Glessgen, F Coen, MD Bloch, D Di Fraia, C Jose, M Borras, K Bucci, R Castells, S Das, A Rendón, C Milella, G Yan, F Levin, A Kadastik, M Chinellato, J Kazhykarim, Y Dobson, M Kashko, P Rovelli, C Ehnis, A Grummer, A Koenig, E Dilsiz, K Papadopoulos, I Sheldon, P Bartosik, N CMS Collaboration Mueller, R Aushev, T Pastika, N Focardi, E Luo, S Roguljic, M Zorbilmez, C Zygala, L Rossin, R Gallinaro, M Smirnov, V Solanki, P Sharma, A Guio, FD Goldouzian, R Nickel, M Nunez Del Prado, A Mohammadi, A Mastronikolis, A Rawal, N Campagnari, C Hildreth, M Marchese, L Tosi, S Sehrawat, A Kang, L Potenza, R Lamichhane, K Wittich, P Choi, M Gokbulut, G Anampa, KH Petkovic, A Voytishin, N Alimena, J Chen, HS Karjavine, V Steggemann, J Xinto, NRM Molnar, J Chen, Y Montero, SC Tricomi, A Shchelina, K Sculac, T Benitez, JF Lo, YF Ivanov, T Jessop, C Myllymäki, M Khan, FA Karneyeu, A Finger, M Smith, N Skovpen, Y Spagnolo, P Akrap, P Lannon, K Viscasillas, EM Anagnostou, G Barroso, AV Blumenfeld, B Lemaitre, V Dasu, S Lawrence, J Pari, M Loukas, N Downham, K Wulff, JW Martinez, MA Grab, C Mcalister, I Nowack, A Zakharov, S Márton, K Yang, S Thom, J Meyer, A Zabolotny, W Rodriguez, M Paolucci, P Lee, H Milieva, A Wallny, R Branson, JG Alves, GA Lutton, L Huwiler, M Mariano, J Szillasi, Z Grieco, C Morentin, MM Koeth, T Lee, Y Rantanen, MM Mastrapasqua, P Tziaferi, E Grenier, G Sikdar, AK Savard, C Hanson, G Li, B Kyriakis, A Takahashi, Y Lee, K Chen, YM Quijada, JAM Ciocci, MA Green, D Hashmi, R Saariokari, S Toikka, NT Redjeb, W Massoteau, B Rosado, P Yang, S Picos, LEC Lee, S Campbell, A Guzzi, L Mao, J Grippo, M Palomo, LV Cockerill, DJA Jabeen, S Gomber, B Pradeep, PB Cittolin, S Milenovic, P Pereira, AV Amsler, C Kasieczka, G Herve, A Rovere, M Tytgat, M Kolberg, T Rabbertz, K Tuominiemi, J Kirschenmann, H Gerber, CE Voutilainen, M Maity, D Mohammed, H Maity, M Attikis, A Shelake, M Bierkens, J Bhattacharya, S Lai, MWK Kronheim, B Cerci, S Luukka, P Bourilkov, D Petrow, H Newbold, DM Reid, M Cazzaniga, C Galli, M Besancon, M Adzic, P Cakir, A McCauley, T Couderc, F Pooth, O Fanò, L Adams, MR Kaya, O Mirabito, L Calandri, A Lewis, N Dejardin, M Frosina, L Govoni, P Theofilatos, K Mahieu, CL Greenberg, B Denegri, D Korcari, W Hundhausen, D Lee, H Razis, PA Wang, X Gupta, H Vander Donckt, M Gu, A Cooper, SI Stahl, A Rossi, B Lee, SW Devouge, P Ayala, G Cattafesta, F Bossini, E Dorigo, T Gaddi, A Arcidiacono, R Moscatelli, F Gill, K Li, W Faure, JL Makarenko, I Das Gupta, S Acharya, S Albrow, M Laroze, D Basile, C Ferri, F Soffi, L Kalogeropoulos, A Meiring, P Budkouski, D Gaigne, P Abel, A Konstantinou, S Raj, S Kramer, T Ille, B Chavez, E Gargiulo, R Breugelmans, N Ganjour, S Sonawane, M Vai, I Gras, P Cavallari, F Almond, J Shin, J Dhingra, N Santanastasio, F Pierini, M Górski, M Sekmen, S Camaiani, B Sakulin, H Amapane, N Ciangottini, D Madrid, C de Monchenault, GH Marckx, D Saltzberg, D Geiser, A Kumar, M Li, Q Hawksworth, M Bloch, P Nargelas, S Saxena, R Lohezic, V Gadkari, D Butz, E Kalbhor, P Wuchterl, S Avati, V Ozek, B Siado, JE Papadimitriou, V Shopova, M Malcles, J Thayil, SA Nigamova, A Mcgrady, C Pinna, D Komurcu, Y Ojalvo, I Dittmann, J Dutta, S Beckers, MR Freeman, J Pozdnyakov, A Turkcapar, S Walsh, R Moore, C Castilla-Valdez, H Orlandi, F Portales, L Borca, C Acosta, D Babbar, J Ronchi, S Tamulaitis, G Yohay, R Alyari, M Musienko, Y Srimanobhas, N Joo, C Ward, R Herndon, M Khan, WA Mascellani, A Meridiani, P Elliot, A Sahin, MÖ Azzi, P Nelson, H Bärtschi, P Lange, W Grzanka, L Kim, J Valuev, V D’Hondt, J King, J Savoy-Navarro, A Hegde, V Topko, B Zuo, X Schmitz, R Husemann, U Alves Gallo Pereira, M Simkina, P Hingrajiya, A Titov, M Sarkar, S Kallonen, KTS Dobur, D Jain, S Von Den Driesch, J An, Y Rout, PK Tornago, M Martins, J Koraka, CK Vaselli, F Chatterjee, S Hou, W-S Kuo, CC Petersen, HA Spanier, S Zotz, A Krohn, M Parmar, N Palmer, C Lin, Z Lentdecker, GD Bilandzija, F Giammanco, A Beaudette, F Gninenko, S Strobbe, N Mankel, A Haubrich, N Pinheiro, JP Zhang, D Migliorini, M Colling, D Glege, F Hare, HS Ellis, KV Boldrini, G Dattamunsi, A Frahm, M Paoletti, S Gritsan, AV Torkian, M Harikrishnan, B Kadlecsik, Á Kennedy, K Glowacki, M Jana, P Andreou, I Rosenzweig, S Busson, P Charlot, C Chiusi, M Pozniak, K Bouhali, O Bollweg, S Canelli, MF Cuisset, TD Crovella, C Teles, PR Paizanos, L Lin, K-Y Dansana, S Clare, R Hofman, DJ Kopp, G Abdullin, S Wang, Z Bacchetta, N Manganote, EJT Garcia-Bellido, A Altork, J Seez, C Ameen, MM Silva, P Flacher, H Majumder, G Lu, N Damas, F Davignon, O Lombardi, F Lai, Y Malberti, M Polikarpov, S Gajownik, J Shvetsov, I Riggirello, M Maravin, Y Wyslouch, B Cassese, A Russell, L Setti, F Savina, M Laer, TV De Wit, A Paramesvaran, S Bisello, D Debnath, T Montoya, CAC Grynyov, B Krupa, J Mantilla, C Amram, O Ledesma, HC Petrucciani, G Diotalevi, T Kilminster, B Aldá Júnior, WL Lavoryk, O Bilei, GM Ehle, IT Fontana Santos Alves, BA Ghosh, S Gilbert, A Figueiredo, DM Vaulin, V Seeba, N Peltola, T Verma, S Gruber, A Pitt, M Prouvost, N Gary, JW Ceccarelli, R Leutgeb, E Granier de Cassagnac, R Zhang, J Teague, D Kwon, H Carvalho, W Diaz, CM Hegeman, J Dincer, GG Radburn-Smith, BC Behera, PK Moureaux, L Katsoulis, P Awan, MIM Shmatov, S Zarucki, M Lobanov, A Da Silva De Araujo, FT Lee, JH Komm, M Szleper, M Ledovskoy, A Su, XF Lourenço, C Osherson, M Kaur, M Harder, K Bortignon, P Donegà, M Kalipoliti, L Keshri, S Olsen, J Nandan, S Zeuner, WD D’Alfonso, M Das, S Moor, AD Lin, J Manoni, M Cheung, HWK Datta, K Mazumdar, K Santoro, A Salvatico, R Danev, P Quadfasel, T Marlow, D Hirosky, R Nguyen, M Malawski, M Obraztsov, S Dziwok, C Singla, A Zanetti, M Islam, N Veszpremi, V Hollar, J Sekhar, S Gecse, Z Mal, P Lopez-Fernandez, R Zhang, L Colin, OM Cruz, SS Ertorer, EY Amoroso, S Strologas, J Lange, D Major, P Wang, L Ochando, C Salerno, R Naskar, K Moon, CS Sauvan, JB Chatterjee, S Dudko, L Kaur, A Harper, S Ayala, E Schuh, T Lambrecht, L Sirois, Y Simsek, AE Shin, J Mendez, LC Amarilo, KM Samalan, A Sowa, L Sokmen, G Alexander, J Sheplock, J Urda Gómez, L Qu, H Padley, BP Celotto, G Iles, G Apollinari, G Brom, J-M Montecassiano, F Longo, E Assiouras, P Ambrozas, M Houghton, C Hakala, J Heikkilä, JK Buontempo, S Flix, J Zabi, A Meng, F Delcourt, M Suryadevara, P Favart, L Grünendahl, S Gutay, L Chen, ZG Zghiche, A Plese, R Joshi, U Agram, J-L Guisao, JM Redjimi, R Ligabue, F Wilson, J Agapitos, A Andrea, J Nayak, A Cormier, K Park, IC Nielsen, C Ciulli, V Markovic, L Damgov, J Chandra, S Doroba, K Cheng, T Jang, W Lowette, S Simpson, F Dogra, S Bala, A Bautista, I Huber, B Brooke, JJ Smith, WH Barbosa, AAR Onsem, GPV Nayak, S Pal, K Iorio, AOM Kello, T Newman, HB van der Linden, J Phor, S Wilson, G Volobouev, I Mikulec, I Carrivale, C Manzoni, RA Lath, A Christoforou, K Raturi, R Swartz, M Zhang, H Konecki, M Grosso, G Ferro, F Misheva, M Jones, M Paganis, E Dancu, JS Guerrero, D Bellora, A Voigtländer, T Reales Gutiérrez, G Meneguzzo, AT Bilin, B Lee, KS Wiederspan, B Elayavalli, RK Sadangi, P Swain, SK Van Den Bossche, N Chatterjee, RM Moran, D Singh, RK Hernandez, MG Raciti, B Bedoya, CF Radchenko, O Varghese, S Safonov, A Araujo, M de Barbaro, P Ban, Y Lemos, DS Vats, D Schieck, J Alpana, A Krintiras, G Paranjpe, MM Chung, H Niendorf, G Innocente, V Lomidze, I Dube, S Motta, J Yanes, E Chabert, EC Hazarika, P Pazzini, J Margoni, M Kaya, M Zhang, F Butalla, S Beauceron, S Latino, G Sphicas, P Andreev, I Kansal, B Das, I Malucchi, M Matthewman, M Lee, Y Pavlov, B Toriashvili, T Laha, A Stadie, H Costa, M Bellan, R Kim, RS Horvath, D You, C Lassila-Perini, K Vandenbroeck, J Lizzo, M Fischer, B Mandal, A Ronchese, P Pernia, DL Reimers, A Rieger, M Sharma, R Sharma, S Leontsinis, S Levchuk, L Cerci, DS Taj, S Aportela, A Mieskolainen, M Tekten, S James, T Cooperstein, S Bach, J Vaish, KY Piccinelli, A Brivio, F Bastos, D Kalinowski, A Neu, C Liu, T Shepherd-Themistocleous, CH Ghosh, S Cerrada, M Primosch, D Magnan, A-M Banerjee, S Bin Norjoharuddeen, N Skipworth, B Kokkas, P Bakhshiansohi, H Triossi, A Nair, LP Vagnerini, A Covarelli, R Civinini, C Jaroslawski, D Bernardes, CA Simonis, HJ Dauncey, P Jafari, A Dalavi, VS Brooks, W Onengut, G Zeinali, M Whalen, KC Tuo, S Parygin, P Evdokimov, O Vitulo, P Butler, PH Lyons, L Albert, A Kim, H Abreu, A Leiton, AGS Sievert, T Mallios, S Akgun, B Kiani, B Savoiu, D Chistov, R Bashiri, S Dordevic, M Stickland, D Santocchia, A Chenarani, S Ramón Álvarez, C Wezenbeek, L Kaadze, K Srivastav, MV Kieseler, J Merino, JL Guo, Q Etesami, SM Malvaso, J Gatti, RD Pisano, M Roberts, A Migliore, E Guzel, AO Lenzi, P Ehataht, K Shalaev, V Spiropulu, M Regnery, B Hosseini, Y Sharko, K Maselli, S Collard, C Paraskevas, I Adams, T Manca, E Pauls, A Marzocchi, B Da Cruz E Silva, CB Gasparini, F Magherini, M Pétré, L Fabozzi, F Robmann, P Del Re, D Coulon, G Qin, X Khakzad, M Khazaie, E Najafabadi, MM Savva, K Flügge, G Kim, D Vlimant, JR Tizchang, S Trevisani, N Gianneios, P Yu, I Bhattacharya, S Falke, S Kolosova, M Al-Mashad, MA Belforte, S Verstege, C Tkaczyk, S Demaria, N Chlebana, F Perez, CMM Kumar, A Alcerro, LFA Felcini, M Senger, M Goerlach, U Gutsche, O Bruschini, D Della Ricca, G Kellogg, RG Strait, J Tully, C Albrecht, A Grunewald, M Sultanov, G Abbrescia, M Sancar, O Choi, J Oh, SB Seo, H Kim, MS Brown, CE An, S Aimè, C Aarrestad, TK Barbieri, M Bein, S Buonsante, M Boletti, A Kumar, S Estrada, CU Del Valle, AE Ko, S Zucchetta, A Ruchti, R Trocino, D Lara, CEP Colaleo, A Park, J Von Cube, RF Olaiya, E Della Penna, L Soha, A Finco, L Tosi, M Tenchini, F Antonello, M Quinnan, M Simonetto, F Leonidou, C Jeppe, L Jiang, C Lu, C Rahatlou, S Harris, RM Steen, A Santpur, SN Creanza, D Hajdu, C Marini, AC Stepennov, A Schleper, P Tsamalaidze, Z D’Anzi, B Gershtein, Y Kim, J Roy, D Saoulidou, N Diaz, D Guthoff, M Anguiano, J Gwak, P Filippis, ND Marozzo, GB Vladimirov, V Horisberger, R Nogima, H Behera, SC Laflotte, I Davies, G Rodriguez, AC Botta, V Duarte, J Schulte, JF Petrilli, A Gurunadha, RG Heyen, F Palma, MD Elmetenawee, W Da Silveira, GG Ferrara, N Cifuentes, JAB Guvenli, AA Quaranta, C Herwig, TC Klima, B Fiore, L Morris, M Kreczko, L Melachroinos, G Goh, J Castaldi, R Longo, L Malik, S Benecke, A Consuegra Rodríguez, S Yang, TJ Saradhy, R Brigljevic, V Shokr, E Salvi, G Pilipovic, D Guglielmi, V Scarfi, S Lee, Y-J Bozzo, M Ferguson, T Mestvirishvili, A Lopez, OG Blancon, B De Souza, RG Louka, M Stone, R Maggi, G Della Negra, M Feld, L Nessi-Tedaldi, F Novak, T Escatel, SA Kang, Y Bell, KW Janot, P Iemmi, F |
| Keywords: | particle physics;physics;High Energy Physics - Experiment (hep-ex) |
| Issue Date: | 3-Dec-2025 |
| Publisher: | Springer Nature |
| Citation: | The CMS Collaboration (2025) 'Determination of the spin and parity of all-charm tetraquarks', Nature, 648 (8092), pp. 58 - 63. doi: 10.1038/s41586-025-09711-7. |
| Series/Report no.: | Report number;CMS-BPH-24-002, CERN-EP-2025-118 |
| Abstract: | The traditional quark model [references (refs 1,2) accounts for the existence of baryons, such as protons and neutrons, which consist of three quarks, as well as mesons, composed of a quark–antiquark pair. Only recently has substantial evidence started to accumulate for exotic states composed of four or five quarks and antiquarks [reference 3]. The exact nature of their internal structure remains uncertain (refs 4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29). Here we report the first measurement of quantum numbers of the recently discovered family of three all-charm tetraquarks (refs 30,31,32), using data collected by the CMS experiment at the Large Hadron Collider from 2016 to 2018 (refs. 33,34). The angular analysis techniques developed for the discovery and characterization of the Higgs boson (refs 35,36,37) have been applied to the new exotic states. Here we show that the quantum numbers for parity P and charge conjugation C symmetries are found to be +1. The spin J of these exotic states is determined to be consistent with 2ħ, while 0ħ and 1ħ are excluded at 95% and 99% confidence levels, respectively. The J<sup>PC</sup> = 2<sup>++</sup> assignment implies particular configurations of constituent spins and orbital angular momenta, which constrain the possible internal structure of these tetraquarks. |
| Description: | Data availability:
Release and preservation of data used by the CMS Collaboration as the basis for publications is guided by the CMS data preservation, re-use and open access policy (https://opendata.cern.ch/record/415). Code availability:
The CMS core software is publicly available at GitHub (https://github.com/cms-sw/cmssw). Extended data figures and tables are available online at: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09711-7#Sec15 . A version of the article is available at arXiv:2506.07944v2 [hep-ex], https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.07944 . Comments: Replaced with the published version. Added the journal reference and the DOI. All the figures and tables can be found at this https://cms-results.web.cern.ch/cms-results/public-results/publications/BPH-24-002 (CMS Public Pages). Report number: CMS-BPH-24-002, CERN-EP-2025-118. Journal reference: Nature 648 (2025) 58. Submission history: From: The CMS Collaboration:
[v1] Mon, 9 Jun 2025 17:06:06 UTC (620 KB); [v2] Thu, 11 Dec 2025 15:34:24 UTC (786 KB). |
| URI: | https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/handle/2438/32503 |
| DOI: | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-09711-7 |
| ISSN: | 0028-0836 |
| Other Identifiers: | ORCiD: Joanne E. Cole https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5638-7599 ORCiD: Akram Khan https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4597-4402 ORCiD: Paul Kyberd https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7353-7090 ORCiD: Ivan D. Reid https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9235-779X CMS-BPH-24-002 CERN-EP-2025-118 arXiv:2506.07944v2 [hep-ex] |
| Appears in Collections: | Dept of Electronic and Electrical Engineering Research Papers
|