| Title: | Evidence of medium response to hard probes using correlations of Z bosons with hadrons in heavy ion collisions |
| Authors: | Chekhovsky, V Hayrapetyan, A Makarenko, V Tumasyan, A Adam, W Andrejkovic, JW Benato, L Bergauer, T Chatterjee, S Damanakis, K Dragicevic, M Ortona, G Joshi, BM Crovella, C Brochero Cifuentes, JA Bainbridge, R Cuevas, J Apollinari, G Rehm, F Chanon, N Zarucki, M Maggi, M Molnar, J Stepennov, A Apresyan, A Veszpremi, V Papadopoulos, A Gavrilov, G Etesami, SM Lu, M Bauerdick, LAT Kim, B Osite, D Valuev, V Knolle, J Bach, J Lavizzari, G Tytgat, M Prosper, H Rendón, C Uribe Estrada, C Rudrabhatla, S Camporesi, T Papakrivopoulos, I Madhusudanan Sreekala, J Naskar, K Cooper, SI Ban, Y Mukherjee, S Schnetzer, S Lucchini, MT Saoulidou, N Tomalin, IR Li, A Creanza, D McCauley, T Pena Rodriguez, KJ Bartek, R Presilla, M Scheurer, V Pieri, M De Wit, A Lychkovskaya, N Grohsjean, A Tully, C Pesaresi, M Menichelli, M Pujahari, PR Naimuddin, M Mocellin, G Mariani, V Deng, S Yang, H Gomes De Souza, R Papadopoulos, I Ignatenko, M Zolkapli, Z Kang, Y Rosowsky, A Cali, IA Franzoni, G Berry, D Nguyen, M Gurrola, A Berryhill, J Mecca, A Bhat, PC Parashar, N Terrill, W Salvini, P Cheng, T Cardwell, B Bourilkov, D Nguyen, D Purohit, A Manthos, N Bianco, M Vaucelle, P Sunar Cerci, D Kyriakis, A Bennett, C Russell, L Fay, J Bianchini, L Louka, M Herwig, TC Kang, L Baxter, S Petyt, D Parida, B Mahon, D Zhang, J Butler, JN My, S Schwarz, D Chen, KF Nowack, A Hong, Y Meridiani, P Bayatmakou, M Alexakhin, V Uzunian, A Kazana, M Mieskolainen, M Da Costa, EM De Favereau De Jeneret, J Painesis, Z Borgonovi, L Yazgan, E Yu, D Dolek, F Blend, D Lawrence, J Ruspa, M Li, Y Kukral, O Castilla-Valdez, H Tadel, M Kumar, S Tali, B Yockey, H Saha, NR Lee, S Bossini, E Zanetti, M Titov, M Fischer, Y Alves Gallo Pereira, M Asenov, P Kim, MR Somalwar, S Stone, R Sharma, A Kousouris, K Stuart, D Piccinelli, A Davies, G Zakharov, S De Guio, F Malawski, M Akgun, B Van Mechelen, P Haller, J Beirão Da Cruz E Silva, C Grandi, C Whalen, KC Candelise, V Amram, D Thayil, SA Baechler, J Abdullin, S Kumar, D Andrea, J Lascio, S Buchmuller, O Qian, S Breedon, R Stafford, D Chauhan, S Brinkerhoff, A Ledovskoy, A Piotrzkowski, K Barbagli, G Tkaczyk, S Shevelev, A Murzin, V Grzanka, L Kosmoglou Kioseoglou, PG Gómez Espinosa, TA Thakur, S Lelas, D Thomas, S Wang, Z Papageorgakis, C Potrebko, A Canepa, A Raicevic, N Vora, J Leonidou, C Adamidis, K Oropeza Barrera, C Pooth, O Folgueras, S Ivone, F Bansal, S Messineo, A Hos, I Choi, J Hsia, HW Zhizhin, I Kozyrev, A Cerati, GB Ally, D Meyer, A Sert, H Garutti, E Shchelina, K Iles, G Adams, T Ferro, F Castro, A Cumalat, JP Delannoy, AG Janot, P Fiorendi, S Primavera, F Yoo, J Giljanovic, D Navarrete Ramos, E Colling, D Jayatilaka, B Sokmen, G Hay, L Kaynak, B Migliore, E Dilsiz, K Bury, F Nayak, S Dumanoglu, I Sekhar, S Lapertosa, A Voytishin, N Robmann, P Fraga, J Pradeep, PB Spagnolo, P Cai, H Kachanov, V Stadie, H Pantaleo, F Roy, P Chen, ZG Korytov, A Beaudette, F Palencia Cortezon, E Mao, Y Sowa, L Solano, A Nuzzo, S Argiro, S Vanlaer, P Fernandez Madrazo, C Vandenbroeck, J Higginbotham, S Kotlinski, D Dominguez, A Major, P Rygaard, L Matorras, F Farkas, K Perera, N Lidrych, J Kadlecsik, Á Engelke, F Crotte Ledesma, H Buchot Perraguin, A Pal, K Hussain, PS Potok, O Quinnan, M Mulhearn, M Johns, W Matorras Cuevas, P Parker, A Martinez Ruiz del Arbol, P Hartmann, F Fontana Santos Alves, BA Holmes, T Mcgrady, C Velasco, M Duarte Campderros, J Kanuganti, AR Obraztsov, S Becerril Gonzalez, H Dziwok, C Chenarani, S Stakia, A Reed, I Nunez Ornelas, M Ogul, H Karunarathna, N Stahl, A Lange, C Yetkin, T Malberti, M Civinini, C Lee, L Sekmen, S Knight, CR Bianco, S Ehle, IT Gharbia, Y Vilela Pereira, A Matchev, K Isik, C Bonacorsi, D De Iorio, A Hashmi, R Munoz Diaz, C Bandyopadhyay, H Neri Huerta, FE Connor, P Gokbulut, G Field, RD Strobbe, N Merkel, P Greenberg, C Kaluzinska, O Von Cube, RF Matos Figueiredo, D Xiao, M Nibigira, E Hollar, J Cousins, R Milella, G Shopova, M Link, M Wiedenbeck, S Orzari, B Laux Kuhn, T Newman, HB Yagil, A Matthewman, M Dash, G Kasieczka, G Bean, A Spanier, S Simpson, F Mousa, J Chokheli, D Lo Meo, S Sharma, S Xie, W Aebi, D Le Mahieu, C Bak, G Eskut, E Sikdar, AK Mijuskovic, J Boyaryntsev, A Butler, PH You, Z Csanád, M Cepeda, M Senger, M Navarro Tobar, Á Vischia, P Ivanov, K Mason, D Guerrero, D Silva, P Kreczko, L Cappati, A Emediato, L Sheokand, T Khalilzadeh, A Szillasi, Z Druzhkin, D Israr, I Tropea, P Ahmad, M Sehrawat, A Ochando, C Nowotny, F Khukhunaishvili, A Akhter, T Hou, W-S Pellecchia, A Casarsa, M Guler, Y Parolia, S Dreimanis, K Cerminara, G Grummer, A Mccarthy, R Missiroli, M Marckx, D Ille, B Menendez, N Tizchang, S Novak, T De La Cruz-Burelo, E Lomidze, I Ziemons, T Montalvo, R Androsov, K Shokr, E Potenza, R Hsu, TH Venditti, R Petrov, A Jung, A Mrenna, S Bashiri, S Prado Pico, J Pozdnyakov, A Behnke, O Krueper, P Mastrapasqua, P Sikler, F Schöfbeck, R Guiducci, L Gouskos, L Collins, E Grynyov, B Aly, R Pedraza, I Kaur, H Ostrom, S Gurpinar Guler, E Khazaie, E Kao, YW Wang, L Stäger, F Bouhali, O Eusebi, R Gilmore, J Huang, T Kamon, T Agyel, D Belvedere, A Simsek, C Smirnov, V Nigamova, A Zotz, A Das, I Giannini, L Mikulec, I Regnery, B Rath, Y Monk, DG Ellis, S Laurila, S Turini, N Ferencek, D Dharmaratna, WGD Petkovic, A Jones, M Tsamalaidze, Z Sahin, MÖ Bonomelli, G Koeth, T Redondo, I Blanco Fernández, S Pacher, L Van Onsem, GP Marzocchi, B Jessop, C Pozniak, K Roland, C Sultanov, G Mcalister, I Salerno, R Wiens, L Zhou, C Majumder, G Zehetner, P De Coen, M Godinovic, N Kim, H Sidiropoulos Kontos, D Salazar Ibarguen, HA Lee, Y Botta, V Sakulin, H Ciocci, MA Fanò, L Noehte, L Mohammadi, A Grosso, G Usai, E Faltermann, N Araujo, M Wardle, N Caillol, C Paus, C Nicolaou, C Matthies, C Nahn, S Greene, S Kwok, KHM Chernyavskaya, N Swartz, M Liu, J Mulders, M Costa, M Würthwein, F Luo, S Martinez, G Langford, J Gastler, D Müller, D Mueller, R Ball, AH Schindler, J Bose, T Urda Gómez, L Aportela, A Funk, W Longo, E Ligabue, F Norberg, S Sphicas, P Yuldashev, BS Bhattacharya, R Clark, SV Cassese, A Laha, A Gallinaro, M Foudas, C Tauqeer, K Neukum, M Bodek, A Besancon, M Carretero, OM Heredia-De La Cruz, I Overton, D Pfeffer, E Mitselmakher, G Florez, C Hakala, J Coldham, K Meola, S Herve, A Tran, NV Colino, N Stamenkovic, M Rodriguez, M Schuh, T Barney, D Choi, J Al Kadhim, A Jensen, F Safonov, A Da Silveira, GG Jain, S Baringer, P Akchurin, N Menzio, L Santanastasio, F Lee, SW Sauvan, JB Damgov, J Maier, B Seez, C Bakas, G Donegà, M Wieland, S Gorbunov, I Mazumdar, K Ayala, E O‘cain, J Martin Viscasillas, E Lee, D Pradhan, R Vico Villalba, C Bilin, B Eble, F Amapane, N Takahashi, Y Karacheban, O Sonawane, M Lutton, L Barria, P Freed, S Verwilligen, P Chwalek, T Gonzalez Lopez, O Röwert, N Baty, A Rodríguez Bouza, V Vage, LH Tiwari, PC Singh, RK Bencze, G Legger, F Koshy, AM Song, JN Pompili, A Maksimovic, P Feng, Y Alcaraz Maestre, J Gogate, N Levchuk, L Karaman, G Mausolf, F Tramontano, R Ranjan, K De Lentdecker, G Mondal, S Ciulli, V Barberis, E Rossi, AM Safdari, M Perelygin, V Evdokimov, O Tricomi, A Li, YY Magherini, M Melo, A Mohrman, K Piedra Gomez, J Wezenbeek, L Lamichhane, K Mehta, A Shadskiy, N Cummings, G Maietto Silverio, I Natoli, J Anthony, D Li, D Pásztor, G Kamtsikis, C Soffi, L Duarte, J Lee, Y Dansana, S Jindariani, S Uvarov, L Banerjee, S Darwish, MR Li, W De Leo, K Lipton, R Gascon, S Scodellaro, L Williams, T Kim, D Kim, MS Claes, DR Bunkowski, K Blekman, F Reales Gutiérrez, G Long, K Parygin, P Yoo, HD Vai, I Perez, CU Roh, Y Stockmeier, L Golf, F Sanchez Cruz, S Lee, K Rossi Tisbeni, S Borras, K Guo, B Reissel, C Bedoya, CF Nielsen, C Bower, S Loeliger, A Sastre, J Das, A Schütze, P Rumerio, P Saka, H Osterberg, K Rieger, M Pearson, E Kiani, B Kar, C Campbell, A Ferri, F Tani, L Paizanos, L Simsek, AE Cardini, A Vats, D Samudio, J Moroni, L Robutti, E Pérez-Calero Yzquierdo, A Kim, TJ Wightman, A Cuisset, TD Khan, FA Lee, SW Colombina, F Dinardo, ME Pena, C Spiropulu, M Yohay, R Aarrestad, TK Pitt, M De Silva, M Barzdukas, A Marquez, J Stahl Leiton, AG Sulimov, V Bahinipati, S Wang, H Giammanco, A Brooke, JJ Vorobyev, A Strait, J Brown, CE Johnson, M Zhokin, A Litov, L Cabrera, A Hu, Z Marlow, D Lintuluoto, A Giassi, A Oh, SB Ivanov, Y Zhao, Y Savin, A Ranieri, A Wei, W Moon, CS Hacisahinoglu, B Tziaferi, E Wayne, M Dobur, D Eckerlin, G Yoon, I Mariano, J Ventura, S Gary, JW Monteno, M Piccolo, D Dittmann, J Waltenberger, W Rothman, S Watson, IJ Geurts, FJM Malik, S Lam, T Bellora, A Rizzi, A Donertas, IS Eckstein, D Chabert, EC Datta, A Estevez Banos, LI Cuffiani, M Malvezzi, S Glowacki, M Martin Perez, C Laktineh, IB Gallo, E Turkcapar, S Murthy, S Sexton-Kennedy, E Galli, M Doroba, K Ellis, KV Zhang, J Rohe, T Fehérkuti, A Shang, V Park, IC Pierini, M Dutta, I Savva, K Charlot, C Sutantawibul, C Zisopoulos, I Parida, G Mantilla, C Assiouras, P Brennan, L Hingrajiya, A Guchait, M Clerbaux, B Gallegos Marañez, LG Montecassiano, F Singh, JB Tenchini, F Gaile, A Czellar, S Christoforou, K Kim, J Terkulov, A Geiser, A Pauls, A Acharya, S D’Alessandro, R Kapsiak, C Lee, MY Guglielmi, V Joshi, U Vila, I Atakisi, IO Smith, N Wang, C Wulff, JW Chinellato, J Kwon, T Calderon De La Barca Sanchez, M Hirosky, R Ptochos, F Vlimant, JR Rinkevicius, A Simone, FM Dermenev, A Fernandez Menendez, J Melachroinos, G Pikurs, G Guthoff, M Strautnieks, NR Dallavalle, GM Dini, P Kress, T Hinzmann, A Elvira, VD Meijers, F Klijnsma, T Bin Anuar, AA Delcourt, M Palit, P Karapostoli, G Bardelli, G Sharma, V Perez Dengra, C Hatakeyama, K Focardi, E Paganoni, M Murray, M Walter, D Lee, JSH Oh, YD Tosi, S Neu, C Glege, F Young, P Bright-Thonney, S Alsufyani, B Strologas, J Schmieder, R Benitez, JF Goldouzian, R Soha, A Bakhshiansohi, H Lee, S Alvarez Gonzalez, B Klima, B Iaydjiev, P Freeman, J Jeppe, L Kaech, B Kasemann, M Kleinwort, C Kogler, R Hirschauer, J Ravera, F Mrowietz, M Palluotto, S Kim, S Rabbertz, K Cavallari, F Gennai, S Alcerro Alcerro, LF Bouchamaoui, H Hossain, J Mignerey, AC Umoret, G Kello, T Rekovic, V Kadastik, M Williams, A Bachtis, M Cussans, D Sessini, MA Fontanesi, E Denegri, D Singla, A Beauceron, S Diotalevi, T Verma, S Roland, G Dutta, V Bernardes, CA Uttley, GP Wilson, J Radburn-Smith, BC Latino, G Mao, J Thomas-Wilsker, J Qian, SJ Lindén, T Nandan, S Wang, Z Taliercio, A Kansal, R Couderc, F Alpana, A Bagliesi, G Ramón Álvarez, C Jiang, C Pisano, M Schmitz, R Han, S Susa, T Komm, M Bautista, I Yi, K Von Den Driesch, J Das, AK Fanfani, A Virdi, AK Primosch, D Yalvac, M Asawatangtrakuldee, C Wang, C Nissan, Y Javaid, T Aarup Petersen, H Krohn, M Demaria, N Errico, F Vaselli, F Palmer, C Hogan, JM Tao, J Krücker, D Verdini, PG Smith, WH Scham, M Samalan, A Koraka, CK Landsberg, G Castaneda Hernandez, A Bein, S Rawal, N Branson, JG Dancu, JS Stickland, D Lange, W Kirakosyan, M Nickel, M Hong, B Kravchenko, I Elliot, A Fabbri, F Leyva Pernia, D Oh, G Organtini, G Jabusch, HR Sahu, B Carrigan, M Brainerd, C Cockerill, DJA Tiras, E Carvalho Antunes De Oliveira, A Sen, S Vetens, W Campagnari, C Shvetsov, I Ozdemir, K Redjeb, W Orfanelli, S Josa, MI Jun, W Kim, YW Flowers, Z Cheung, HWK Hong, J Pastrone, N Erdmann, J Sarkar, S Mersi, S Lipka, K Lohmann, W Sola, V Gninenko, S Cetorelli, F Martins, J Soto Rodríguez, A Zimermmane Castro Santos, A Granier de Cassagnac, R Steen, A Labe, F Shalaev, V Wanczyk, J Morse, DM Li, C Nürnberg, A Onel, Y Spitzbart, D Faure, JL Campana, M Gavrilov, V Band, R Lorkowski, F Ingram, Q Mannelli, M Delaere, C Iqbal, MA Hernandez, JM Mankel, R León Holgado, J Reis, T Diemoz, M Conway, J Dube, S Melzer-Pellmann, I-A Allmond, B Hadley, NJ Yang, S Gedia, K Park, K Tae, B Gottmann, A Seixas, J Lee, Y-J Trevisani, N Vagnerini, A Carrillo Montoya, CA Hadley, M Breugelmans, N Forthomme, L Sawant, S Pedrini, D Paulini, M Shepherd-Themistocleous, CH Tlisova, I Staiano, A Yoo, S Liang, Z Kirschenmann, H Holmberg, M-L Yusuff, I Consuegra Rodríguez, S Bocci, A Bellan, R Wachirapusitanand, V Marcellini, S Slabospitskii, S Akpinar, A Hegde, V Haeberle, R Harris, RM Thiel, M Kalinowski, A Yu, I Hall, G Boudoul, G Paranjpe, MM Vizan Garcia, JM Skovpen, K Lai, Y Mendizabal Morentin, M d’Enterria, D Zotto, P Meyer, AB Butalla, S De Bruyn, I Ceccarelli, R Gecse, Z Mejia Guisao, J Riccardi, C Paasch, A Thachayath, A Pfeiffer, A Liao, H Bargassa, P Lecoq, P Klyukhin, V Mormile, M CMS collaboration Meschi, E Lincoln, D Hauser, J Shchedrolosiev, M Chatzistavrou, T Glessgen, F Golubev, N Yi, R Boletti, A Moral Figueroa, K Lo, YF Babbar, J Rathjens, D Cazzaniga, C De Jesus Damiao, D Elkafrawy, T Grab, C Mishra, S Assran, Y Choi, M Ko, S Salvi, G Winer, BL Bhattacharya, S Jain, S Chavez, E Wolf, R De Palma, M Bozzo, M Goerlach, U Chou, PC Meuser, D Kyberd, P Mallampalli, A Radogna, R Cosby, C Corcodilos, L Liu, T Liyanage, K Yuan, L An, S Yang, S Maravin, Y Perego, A Pinolini, BS Lin, J Kapoor, A Merschmeyer, M Azarkin, M Lu, R-S Harilal, A Yang, TJ Pinna, D Della Ricca, G Maghrbi, Y Rohilla, A Sharma, V Toropin, A Leutgeb, E Pizzati, G Hill, C Bin Norjoharuddeen, N Wang, J Gill, K Chaudhary, G Popov, V Szleper, M Zghiche, A Vojinovic, M Brücken, E Ascioti, ME Crossman, B Santpur, SN Lange, J Kaur, M Martikainen, L Wyslouch, B Fedi, G Lopez-Fernandez, R Dordevic, M Ragazzi, S Jana, P Kaur, A Kellogg, RG Mussgiller, A Mcginn, C Tabarelli de Fatis, T Delgado Peris, A Harris, P Datta, K Castells, S Wang, J Tapper, A Pastika, N Afanasiev, S Lu, C Kumar, S Di Marco, E Nair, LP Buontempo, S Caminada, L Budkouski, D Srimanobhas, N Miguel Colin, O Khein, L Brommer, S Bryant, P Krutelyov, V Cagnotta, A Sharma, R Alves, GA Downham, K Wittig, F Milenovic, P Osherson, M Chistov, R Evard, H Deile, M Hohlmann, M Zuo, X Palichik, V Ho, KW Dasu, S Siamarkou, E Li, AJ Aldá Júnior, WL Madrid, C Petrilli, A Spiegel, L Agram, J-L Mulargia, R Cankocak, K Dolen, J Toms, M Romeo, F Schleper, P Abbaneo, D Hildreth, M Bell, KW Gupta, H Manca, E Wang, J Lee, KS Savoy-Navarro, A Almond, J Carnevali, F Gadkari, D Luukka, P Adloff, C Musienko, Y Magnan, A-M Zygala, L Seo, H Mallios, S Summers, S D’Alfonso, M Dejardin, M Zhao, J Andreev, Y Klein, K Le Bihan, A-C Zucchetta, A Nelson, H Kansal, B Moore, C Isildak, B Botta, C Cavallo, N Khakzad, M Marinelli, N Fabozzi, F Dabrowski, A Härringer, N Backhaus, M Citron, M Sahasransu, AR Busson, P Troiano, D Iorio, AOM Bryas Dexmiers D‘archiac, PD Gershtein, Y Kodolova, O Roberts, A Vámi, TÁ Lista, L Wadud, MA Korotkikh, V Xie, S Belloni, A Ha, S Schröder, M Herndon, M Guiang, J Sheldon, P Dincer, GG Eno, SC Jaiswal, A Kovalskyi, D Goh, J Quadfasel, T Verma, P Antonello, M Milosevic, V Bakshi, AS Liko, D Papadimitriou, V Faccioli, P Paolucci, P Di Florio, A Meiring, P León Coello, M Bundock, A Petkov, P Nogima, H Beyrouthy, T Reithler, H Teroerde, M Negro, G Kokkas, P Rossi, B Lorusso, M Escalante Del Valle, A Qu, H Levin, A Barton, B Camaiani, B Ardino, R Hajdu, C Everaerts, P De Castro, G Kolosova, M Korenkov, V Novak, A Fokow, P Lyons, L Haddad, Y Mankel, A Liu, Y Arneodo, M Albrecht, A Schwanenberger, C Padley, BP Kveton, A Auffray, E Anagnostou, G Reid, ID Merlin, JA Sharma, R Varghese, S de Barbaro, P Azzi, P Reyes Vega, JA David, A Ebrahimi, A Brivio, F Bacchetta, N Tuo, S Nunez Del Prado, A Galloni, C Zecchinelli, AG Bistany-riebman, J Elmer, P Schnake, S Gomber, B Halkiadakis, E Kim, HS Moortgat, F Schwandt, J Shukla, R Eysermans, J Rabady, D De Cosa, A Menasce, D Coelho, E Peltola, T Masterson, P Velkovska, J Cooperstein, S Wuchterl, S Bollweg, S Chertok, M Kovac, M Pavlov, B Harte, TG Savrin, V Yang, UK Law, KH White, R Gilbert, A Garcia, F Lanev, A Moran, D Krupa, J Cole, JE Meena, M He, H Erbacher, R Viinikainen, J Volobouev, I Bortignon, P Bortolato, G Bulla, ACM Carlin, R Checchia, P Black, K Hits, D Ershov, A Basile, C Dissertori, G Polikarpov, S Perries, S Trocino, D Robertshaw, L Erdmann, W Bruno, G Ghosh, S Chawla, R Lu, N Gregores, EM Rovelli, T Ribeiro Lopes, B Kailasapathy, B Lath, A Beri, SB Sculac, A Loukas, N Cavanaugh, R Yang, YC D’Anzi, B Haza, G Behera, SC Murillo Quijada, JA Longo, L De Roeck, A Kole, G Krolikowski, J Zhang, H Hindrichs, O Devetak, D Dorigo, T Kronheim, B Lavezzo, L Roy, D Riti, F Gardner, P McBride, P Gutsche, O Heindl, M Saini, MK Kumar, M Zorbilmez, C Joo, C Raidal, M Dezoort, G Ameen, MM Fernández Del Val, D Onengut, G Bonanomi, M Wichmann, K Fackeldey, P Tsipolitis, G Ramírez García, M Wildridge, A Kim, RS Pérez Adán, D Gasparini, F Giffels, M Snigirev, A Ryu, MS Gasparini, U Zarubin, A Gülmez, E Rossi, A Dobson, M Grenier, G Lange, D Huh, C Noonan, D Redjimi, R Cunqueiro Mendez, L Lee, C Gerosa, R Li, Q Venkatasubramanian, N Ruiz Alvarez, JD Dauncey, P Brew, C Flacher, H Padula, SS Dervan, J Freer, C Giorgetti, S Heath, HF Sommerhalder, M Marozzo, GB Vitulo, P Battilana, C Zhu, RY Lobanov, A Han, Y Sirois, Y Varela, J Kirsanov, M Joyce, M Abreu, A Butz, E Falke, S Lusiani, E Oh, BH Katsoulis, P Correia Silva, G Das, S Li, B Singh, N Defranchis, MM Margoni, M Radchenko, O Kwon, H Harder, K Palla, F Tsatsos, A Llorente Merino, J Boldrini, G Dittmer, S Roy, T Vander Velde, C Lannon, K Gwak, P Rosenzweig, S Wiederspan, B Chandra, S Belforte, S Ferrara, N Vaandering, EW Lenzi, P Diaz, D Ozkorucuklu, S Orimoto, T Maier, S Hurtado Anampa, K Guzel, AO Kunnawalkam Elayavalli, R Demiragli, Z Richards, A Wulansatiti, M Costa, S Ahmad, A Saltzberg, D Meneguzzo, AT Bonilla, J Migliorini, M Finger, M Daskalakis, G Zeuner, WD Appelt, E Hiltbrand, J Asilar, E Bruschini, D Nayak, A Grieco, C Keicher, P Tonelli, G Oh, M Mei, H Razis, PA Jung, AW Braghieri, A Malara, A Bhyun, JH Pazzini, J Neumeister, N Smith, VJ Park, J Juodagalvis, A Ujvari, B Malakhov, A Jafari, A Nash, J Muthirakalayil Madhu, A Mirabito, L Rogan, C Kim, J Vazzoler, F Pandolfi, F Jeon, S Inkaew, P Paoletti, S Ozek, B Krammer, N Ruchti, R Aushev, T Merlo, J-P Alhusseini, M Vijay, A Revering, M Lustermann, W Sarkisovi, V Das Gupta, S Ivanov, A Gray, L Gras, P Sanders, S Belyaev, A Tornago, M Krommydas, I Gujju Gurunadha, R Hussain, MM Shumka, E Behera, PK Bylsma, B Novaes, SF Dierlamm, A Giommi, L Schmitt, MH Grunewald, M Lin, W Hamel de Monchenault, G Goy Lopez, S Ganjour, S Prova, PR Cutts, D Lyon, A-M Martinez Rivero, C de Trocóniz, JF Fernández Ramos, JP Petrow, H Manzoni, RA Luo, J Ford, WT Cremonesi, M Miao, Y Mestvirishvili, A Chatterjee, RM Bermúdez Martínez, A Ryou, Y Ronchese, P Marchegiani, M Kallil Tharayil, A Schmidt, A Horzela, M Konstantinou, S Acosta, D Marchese, L Tavernier, S Horvath, D Rotter, J Barroso Ferreira Filho, M Benelli, G Macedo, M Matveev, V Paramatti, R Kutzner, V Das, P Ventura Barroso, A Borca, C Pinheiro, JP Leonardo, N Santoro, A Chen, HS Ngadiuba, J King, J Gargiulo, R Konecki, M Cipriani, M Hanson, G Poncet, O Tonjes, MB Warden, A Pugliese, G Yoo, J Mascellani, A Barbosa Trujillo, DA Fiore, L Burkett, K Gouzevitch, M Yanes, E Alison, J Kallonen, KTS van der Linden, J Smith, C Meschini, M Masetti, G Contardo, D Stephans, GSF Ristori, L Lee, J Nessi-Tedaldi, F Hegeman, J Pauss, F Lee, R Sanchez, A Olsen, J Wood, D Neutelings, I Perovic, V Jang, W Vannerom, D Klanner, R Rusack, R Oreshkin, V Husemann, U Houghton, C Liu, Z-A D’Amante, V Royon, C Starodumov, A Ranken, E Abdullah Al-Mashad, M Rantanen, MM Andreou, I Castaldi, R Bilei, GM Richman, J Diekmann, S Quast, G Rohlf, J Kim, H Zhang, L Stoynev, S Chen, YM Rose, A De La Cruz, B Erdmann, M Grippo, M Pigazzini, S Dimitrov, A Mondal, S Yan, X Zejdl, P Ristic, B Walsh, R Townsend, A Janssen, T Korcari, W Awais, A Morris, M Mota Amarilo, K Liu, G Ajmal, S Flix, J Seth, C Nabili, S Arora, A Quaranta, C Bucci, R Jiang, CH Jabeen, S Keshri, S Letts, J Kanemura, M Calandri, A Seidita, R Raspereza, A Paspalaki, G Wang, D Wei, K Lee, H Aldaya Martin, M Sarica, U Dell’Orso, R Mcginnis, M Lampé, T Zhang, D Hart, A Márton, K Demina, R Popescu, S Lin, Z Carrivale, C Ojalvo, I Mal, P Bhardwaj, A Kieseler, J Howard, A Chen, M Popova, E Abbrescia, M Kramer, T Roguljic, M Agarwal, G Wang, Q Encinas Acosta, HA Rastorguev, D Steggemann, J Tarabini, A Valsecchi, D Wallny, R Amsler, C Hundhausen, D Polatoz, A Hassani, A Elicabuk, U Paramesvaran, S Aruta, C Liu, C Evangelou, I Abbiendi, G Mohanty, GB Lee, JH Bhattacharya, S Alverson, G Puerta Pelayo, J Maity, D Van Hove, P Petrushanko, S Karathanasis, G Simkina, P Lasaosa García, C Lourenço, C Masciovecchio, M Fangmeier, C Chatterjee, S Flügge, G Seidel, M Lange, T Tuominiemi, J Babaev, A Bornheim, A Zalewski, P Trapote, A Jaffel, K Hoorani, HR Hosseini, Y Verdier, P Fernandez, M Russell, T Lammel, S Ciangottini, D Iashvili, I Kumar, N Penzo, A Cerrada, M Bärtschi, P Hoang, D Calligaris, L Iemmi, F Fonseca De Souza, S Mukherjee, S Feld, L Pétré, L Karchin, PE Sharma, A Tok, UG Sánchez Hernández, A Dittmar, M Mishra, T Kolberg, T Bauer, G Dhingra, N Kalipoliti, L Asghar, MI Canelli, MF Uplegger, L Donato, S Bhowmik, D Jaroslawski, D Azzurri, P Manoni, M Choi, J Steinbrück, G Jourd‘huy, E Danilov, M Lunerti, L Cormier, K Finco, L Rádl, AJ Snyder, C Suryadevara, P Mokhtar, F Huwiler, M Simonis, HJ Konigsberg, J Boran, F Abbott, S Silvestris, L Zabi, A Kim, V Theofilatos, K Tsoi, HF Marini, AC Dodonova, A Walkingshaw Pass, K Loveless, R Horisberger, R Yao, Y Skinnari, L Avila, C Anguiano, J Niedziela, J Prifti, E Escobar Franco, R Treille, D Yu, SS Jakovcic, K Laroze, D Jin, W Gerber, CE Rahatlou, S Alazemi, F Ivanov, T Paganis, E Brondolin, E Yigitbasi, E Kara, O Venturi, A Attikis, A Hazarika, P Bluj, M Paraskevas, I Chiusi, M Lopez Ruiz, R Benecke, A Bartosik, N Mohammadi Najafabadi, M Jofrehei, A Wulz, C-E Liu, M Lee, H Kilminster, B Blinov, V Karneyeu, A Cherepanov, V Heyen, F Sagir, S Leontsinis, S Gadallah, MMA Nemes, F Gritsan, AV Alimena, J Ye, Z Cerci, S Kalogeropoulos, A Bhattacharya, S Cooke, C Bhowmik, S Abdalla, H De Moor, A Dogra, S Myllymäki, M Manganelli, N Amoroso, S Krasnikov, N Arcidiacono, R Hawksworth, M Saha, G Ramirez Guadarrama, DL Cabrillo, IJ Shulha, S Rovere, M Wenzl, DA Askew, A Rykaczewski, H Xiang, Y Obertino, MM Malcles, J Lassila-Perini, K Innocente, V Sharko, K Saradhy, R Sorrentino, G Gribushin, A Malgeri, L Kaur, A Wan, Y Kim, Y Fasanella, D Liechti, SP Brigljevic, V Macchiolo, A Klute, M Moon, DH Sheplock, J Rübenach, J Goncharov, M Gandrakota, A Uslan, E Barone, G Pathak, A Stojanovic, M Gu, A Rolandi, G Clement, E Siviero, F Piperov, S Yang, Y Blancon, B Ceard, L Bloch, P Rovelli, C Lohezic, V Siado, JE Meng, F Depasse, P Mills, C Calzaferri, S Hadjiagapiou, A Lee, H Lavoryk, O Pedro, K Morcillo Perez, CM Kaadze, K Arteaga Escatel, S Kirpichnikov, D Zaza, A Mora Herrera, C Salyer, K Santocchia, A Linacre, J Tabb, W Huber, B Chhetri, A Scarfi, S Van Laer, T Boccali, T Clare, R Orlandi, F Vellidis, K Favart, L Van Putte, S Muhammad, A Veres, GI Qin, X Pearkes, J Papanastassiou, A Bubanja, I Bevilacqua, T Carvalho, W Cox, B Kamble, S Soeiro, M Pilipovic, D Banerjee, S Bala, A Lipinski, M Brandao Malbouisson, H Gutay, L Savard, C Sözbilir, Ü Awan, MIM Chitroda, BK Virdee, T Biino, C Mans, J Giani, S Pata, J Gonzalez Caballero, I Grünendahl, S Komaragiri, JR Kayis Topaksu, A Khan, A Koenig, E Kalbhor, P Boos, E Gomez-Ceballos, G Rejeb Sfar, H Schonbeck, N Gleyzer, SV Winterbottom, D Motta, J Dutta, S Stenson, K Krishna, A Saumya, S Nash, K Felcini, M Dulemba, JL Ehataht, K Gianneios, P Da Molin, G Suarez, I Chang, P Reimers, A Ulmer, KA Taus, R Muraleedharan Nair Bindhu, VK Aravind, A Sguazzoni, G Luongo, F Zaleski, S Xiao, J Wagner, SR Navarria, FL Kang, DY Eich, N Harper, S Rappoccio, S Mastrapasqua, V Cartiglia, N Kopp, G Lawhorn, JM Manolopoulos, K Tenchini, R Harikrishnan, B Spiga, D Chahal, GS Fischer, B Hwang, K Rossin, R Kuo, CC Gigi, D Adams, MR Teague, D Lemaitre, V Brown, RM Fiorina, D Kaya, M Basnet, A Colaleo, A Vanden Bemden, M Lowette, S Wolf, M Blumenfeld, B Wickramarathna, DDC Roskes, J Zipper, N Tran, TT Calderon, A Chen, Y Ramos, D Krintiras, G Skovpen, Y Zhang, Y Choudhary, BC Gomez, G Avati, V Tonelli Manganote, EJ Salvatico, R James, T Margjeka, I Agapitos, A Maggi, G Karjavine, V Yates, BR Zuolo, D Cox, PT Iaselli, G Alexander, J Frankenthal, A Laflotte, I Brom, J-M Carrera Jarrin, E Aleksandrov, A Cittolin, S Chen, X Reichert, J Ghezzi, A Roy Chowdhury, S An, Y Sun, X Wassmer, M Mariotti, C Spah, JL Lambrecht, L Wilson, G Kaya, O Rebello Teles, P Vander Donckt, M Montagna, P Csorgo, T Sperka, D Baradia, S Davis, J Zorbakir, IS Erice, C Tsai, LS Schulte, JF Paggi, G Tarricone, C Yan, F Cranshaw, DJ Misheva, M Kazhykarim, Y Baldenegro Barrera, C Nikitenko, A Ayala, G Mundim, L Baden, A Kaestli, HC Di Mattia, A Fayer, S Dickinson, J Vourliotis, E Levchenko, P Agrawal, A Bialkowska, H Vernazza, E Setti, F Fan, J Tedeschi, T Portales, L Savoiu, D Sarkar, T Dutta, S Ruales Barbosa, AA Dimova, T Sadangi, P Simonetto, F Zeinali, M Su, XF Rout, PK Viliani, L Mercadante, PG Durkin, LS Newbold, DM Voutilainen, M Neogi, O Sznajder, A Lau, KT Fan, X Tomei, TRFP Greenberg, B Chiarito, B Ferguson, T Hogan, S Pelliccioni, M Dozen, C Aimé, C Davignon, O Kuo, CM Shen, X Govoni, P Kyriacou, S Wang, F Tekten, S Mahmoud, MA Kumar, A Carnahan, T Saha, P Kim, S Tosi, M Hebbeker, T Menezes De Oliveira, T Makarenko, I Garcia-Bellido, A Tsionou, D Bloch, D Nadderd, L Valencia Palomo, L Markovic, L Lazarovits, M Vardanyan, I Lemos, DS Antchev, G Leguina, P Scribano, A Hahn, KA Van Den Bossche, N Veelken, C Alexe, CA Collard, C Re, V Triossi, A Kotamnives, P Monroy, J Oshiro, M Patterson, JR Reid, M Moscatelli, F Musich, M Zoi, I Salur, S Covarelli, R Petrucciani, G Hofman, DJ Teryaev, O Chou, JP Kim, J Bragagnolo, A Zabolotny, W Ambrozas, M Schieck, J Ecklund, KM Sculac, T Massironi, A Uchida, K Milosevic, J Elmetenawee, W Müller, T Zhang, F Dugad, S Chudasama, R Bendavid, J Flores Avila, G Haubrich, N Chung, H Bloom, K Khan, WA Benaglia, A Wang, D Bhatnagar, V Barman, S Zilizi, G Fernández Manteca, PJ Lizzo, M Albrecht, S Selivanova, D Guzzi, L McMaster, B Golutvin, I Shelake, M Vazquez Escobar, J Capiluppi, P Bam, B Li, J Lanaro, A Wu, HY Karmakar, S Cavallo, FR Jaramillo, J Bartolini, M Shahzad, MA Selvaggi, M Ryd, A Chen, GM Maselli, S Varelas, N Thom, J Del Re, D Kwan, S Monti, F Giacomelli, P Raciti, B El Morabit, K Benussi, L Avery, P Wissing, C Mudholkar, T Górski, M Adzic, P Andreev, V Golovtcov, V Savina, M Tamulaitis, G Raturi, R Kumar, A Wittich, P Shmatov, S Cakir, A Green, D Gu, Y Torres Da Silva De Araujo, F Komurcu, Y Swain, SK Hadjiiska, R Kharchilava, A Vladimirov, V Stamerra, A Bestintzanos, I Heikkilä, JK Zou, R Grove, D Della Negra, M Ko, B Thomas, L Bastos, D Voigtländer, T Kennedy, K Albrow, M Cossutti, F Sosnov, D Reinsvold Hall, A Damas, F Tsai, E Amendola, C Vaish, KY Topko, B Lee, K De Filippis, N Tews, A Aydilek, O Perrotta, A Nanda, S Campos, D Moureaux, L Cerri, O Lethuillier, M Finger, M Bethani, A Caputo, C Lee, J Zumerle, G D’Hondt, J Borshch, V Hofsaess, R Incandela, J Park, MI El Mamouni, H Alyari, M Amram, O Jeitler, M Olaiya, E Parmar, N Hensel, C Lehti, S Köseyan, OK Maeshima, K Heintz, U Eliseev, D Taylor, L Goldstein, J Hoepfner, K Fouz, MC Siroli, GP Chlebana, F Choi, S |
| Keywords: | CMS;heavy ions;nuclear experiment (nucl-ex);high energy physics - experiment (hep-ex) |
| Issue Date: | 25-Dec-2025 |
| Publisher: | Elsevier |
| Citation: | Chekhovsky, V. et al. for the benefit of the CMS collaboration (2026) 'Evidence of medium response to hard probes using correlations of Z bosons with hadrons in heavy ion collisions', Physics Letters B, 874, 140120, pp. 1–16. doi: 10.1016/j.physletb.2025.140120. |
| Series/Report no.: | Report number;CMS-HIN-23-006, CERN-EP-2025-046 |
| Abstract: | The first measurement of pseudorapidity and azimuthal angle distributions relative to the momentum vector of a Z boson for low transverse momentum (p<sub>T</sub>) charged hadrons in lead-lead (PbPb) collisions is presented. By studying the hadrons produced in an event with a high-p<sub>T</sub> Z boson (40 < p<sub>T</sub> < 350 GeV), the analysis probes how the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) medium created in these collisions affects the parton recoiling opposite to the Z boson. Utilizing PbPb data at a nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass energy √|b|𝒔<sub>NN</sub> = 5.02 TeV from 2018 with an integrated luminosity of 1.67 nb⁻¹ and proton-proton (pp) data at the same energy from 2017 with 301 pb⁻¹, the distributions are examined in bins of charged-hadron p<sub>T</sub>. A significant modification of the distributions for charged hadrons in the range 1 < p<sub>T</sub> < 2 GeV in PbPb collisions is observed when compared to reference measurements from pp collisions. The data provide new information about the correlation between hard and soft particles in heavy ion collisions, which can be used to test predictions of various jet quenching models. When compared with theoretical predictions, the results are consistent with expectations of a hydrodynamic wake created when the QGP is depleted of energy by the parton propagating through it. Therefore, this Letter presents the first evidence of probe-induced energy depletion and the resulting response by the QGP medium. |
| Description: | A version of the article is available at arXiv:2507.09307v2 [nucl-ex] (https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.09307). Comments: Replaced with the published version. Added the journal reference and the DOI. All the figures and tables can be found at https://cms-results.web.cern.ch/cms-results/public-results/publications/HIN-23-006 (CMS Public Pages). Report number: CMS-HIN-23-006, CERN-EP-2025-046. Journal reference: Phys. Lett. B 874 (2026) 140120. Submission history: From: The CMS Collaboration: [v1] Sat, 12 Jul 2025 14:49:43 UTC (444 KB); [v2] Mon, 23 Feb 2026 02:01:13 UTC (444 KB). Data availability:
Release and preservation of data used by the CMS Collaboration as the basis for publications is guided by the CMS data preservation, re-use and open access policy. Supplementary materials are available online at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0370269325008767?via%3Dihub#sec0009 . |
| URI: | https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/handle/2438/33110 |
| DOI: | https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2025.140120 |
| ISSN: | 0370-2693 |
| Other Identifiers: | ORCiD: Joanne E. Cole https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5638-7599 ORCiD: Akram Khan https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4597-4402 ORCiD: Paul Kyberd https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7353-7090 ORCiD: Ivan D. Reid https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9235-779X |
| Appears in Collections: | Department of Electronic and Electrical Engineering Research Papers
|